Skip to content

Why Does Scrapebox Achieve Higher Verified Blog Comments Than GSA SER?

seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia
in GSA Search Engine Ranker

I have a question regarding the difference in results between Scrapebox Poster and GSA Search Engine Ranker.

When I use Scrapebox Poster, I’m able to get around 15,000 blog comments approved and verified (mostly on WordPress sites). However, when I use GSA SER on the same list of 15,000 URLs, I only end up with about 300 to 400 verified comments.

I would like to understand why there is such a significant difference in verified results between the two tools when using the same targets.

Thank you in advance for your insights.

Tagged:

Comments

  • SvenSven www.GSA-Online.de
    I cant tell without further details, please send the URLs you did with scrapebox in private message and I have a look which one fails and why and update the scripts.
  • seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia
    Okay perfect @Sven , i will send the details in a private message. Thank you!
  • SvenSven www.GSA-Online.de
    I had a chance to look at this and found the following:
    • 1. The default filter to download a website is set to 1MB in size. Most of the sites you gave me are way bigger in size (10MB or more). That results in a incomplete download and usually the form to submit comments in at the bottom. So these sites will not be identified correctly
    • 2. Many URLs are duplicate domains. From 19xxx URLs, only 1380 are from unique domains. So many get skipped either to being previously submitted to or they failed before.

    Why I think this is still correct:
    • 1. Submitting your URL to a totally spammed and then large site seems meaningless to me. I would not submit there as it could hurt your ranking.
    • 2. Spamming a domain on different URLs is also not worth it in terms of SEO.

    If you still want to submit there:
    • 1. Increase the global filter setting form 1MB to like 20MB. Also decrease threads as many threads will now waste a lot of memory while parsing the sites.
    • 2. In project settings set it to allow submitting on the same site again
  • cherubcherub SERnuke.com
    Googlebot will only crawl max 2MB of any supported file type, html included: https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/googlebot
    Considering G will also only look at the first 100 ext links on a page, even 1MB is probably too big.
  • seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia
    Thanks for this! I’m going to review and apply these updates now. I'll keep you posted on the results, especially as I integrate them into the tiered link building stages.

    Thank you very much!
  • SvenSven www.GSA-Online.de
    @cherub ones posted, the link will sometimes appear at top of listing so for a short time it may be visible by google on such spammed sites, but even then it's not worth it in my eyes.
  • MasumKhanMasumKhan Dhaka
    Yes, He is really right. I tested three software, the first winner is PTCS, 2nd - ScrapeBox, 3rd - GSA SER. I think SER blog comment engine, penetration, submission, and verification are unlike the other two software.
  • SvenSven www.GSA-Online.de
    @MasumKhan well you can configure SER to post there, but you need to make changes to default settings. BUT I don't think it's worth it!
  • royalmiceroyalmice WEBSITE: ---> https://asiavirtualsolutions.com | SKYPE:---> asiavirtualsolutions
    MasumKhan said:
    Yes, He is really right. I tested three software, the first winner is PTCS, 2nd - ScrapeBox, 3rd - GSA SER. I think SER blog comment engine, penetration, submission, and verification are unlike the other two software.
    What does  PTCS stand for ?
  • seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia

    Hi @Sven , thank you very much. I have updated the settings and I’m now getting better results, especially with more verified links in Tier 2 and Tier 3.

    I have one question regarding Tier 3. At the moment, the Tier 3 indexer is generating roughly the same number of backlinks as the Tier 2 blog comments.

    What I would like to achieve is a higher ratio for Tier 3. For example, if the campaign creates 1,000 Tier 2 blog comments, I would like Tier 3 to generate around 3,000 indexer backlinks.

    I will share the screenshot in inbox. Could you please guide me on which settings I should adjust in GSA SER to achieve this kind of scaling?

    Thank you!

  • SvenSven www.GSA-Online.de
    Well, not much to see on that screenshot. I can only guess that the "per URL" checkbox is not checked.
  • MasumKhanMasumKhan Dhaka
    royalmice said:
    MasumKhan said:
    Yes, He is really right. I tested three software, the first winner is PTCS, 2nd - ScrapeBox, 3rd - GSA SER. I think SER blog comment engine, penetration, submission, and verification are unlike the other two software.
    What does  PTCS stand for ?
    Yeah, you come to the point. This is a very old SEO application, PingBack, Trackback, Comment submitter. This application is no longer available.
    Thanked by 1royalmice
  • MasumKhanMasumKhan Dhaka
    seo_ranker said:

    Hi @Sven , thank you very much. I have updated the settings and I’m now getting better results, especially with more verified links in Tier 2 and Tier 3.

    I have one question regarding Tier 3. At the moment, the Tier 3 indexer is generating roughly the same number of backlinks as the Tier 2 blog comments.

    What I would like to achieve is a higher ratio for Tier 3. For example, if the campaign creates 1,000 Tier 2 blog comments, I would like Tier 3 to generate around 3,000 indexer backlinks.

    I will share the screenshot in inbox. Could you please guide me on which settings I should adjust in GSA SER to achieve this kind of scaling?

    Thank you!

    Where are the settings, because I need to update SER for blog comment settings.
  • royalmiceroyalmice WEBSITE: ---> https://asiavirtualsolutions.com | SKYPE:---> asiavirtualsolutions
    MasumKhan said:
    royalmice said:
    MasumKhan said:
    Yes, He is really right. I tested three software, the first winner is PTCS, 2nd - ScrapeBox, 3rd - GSA SER. I think SER blog comment engine, penetration, submission, and verification are unlike the other two software.
    What does  PTCS stand for ?
    Yeah, you come to the point. This is a very old SEO application, PingBack, Trackback, Comment submitter. This application is no longer available.
    I am an old SEO guy, and I never heard of a tool called PTCS
    There used to be a tool called Bookmarking Daemon, but I guess it is not the same.

    to answer your question to @Sven

    You could set the Tier 2 to stop when it reached 1000 verified links, and then set Tier 2 to stop when it reached 3000 verified links. That is the very first setting under the project options tab.
  • seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia
    Thank you @Sven @royalmice, I have updated the settings and now it's resolved.

    Thank you again.
    Thanked by 1royalmice
  • seo_rankerseo_ranker Asia
    @Sven, please check the inbox. thank you!
Sign In or Register to comment.