Changling pagelink after penalty
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fef5b/fef5b76c078c40e2684158a4f05a85c12d3bf286" alt="spunko2010"
Hi, Just a quick question to try to get consensus on this, as there's a lot of information around but I prefer first-hand experiences
Let's say I build links to a URL and get penalised by Google, eg: www.mydomain.com/my-keyword. If I then move the content and don't setup a 301, to www.mydomain.com/mykeyword1 , would there still be a risk of penalising? Or is that classed as a new page, even though the content is identical?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2aaea/2aaeae8ddd2de6a58461c60037d81e999d54b520" alt=":) :)"
Comments
If you do the above, and there are no hyperlinks or 301 redirects between the 2 sites, then no penalty can pass to the new site.